Note: I have been meaning to write something like this for a long time now. But with a lot of distractions, I never really found the time till now. It may not be relevant to everyone now, but it still is relevant to me.
A cab ride in Bombay is quite an easy experience. One does not have to wait on end for a cab driver willing to take you to your destination or haggle for a rate. One just flags down a passing cab and gives the destination address. Oh, and above all this, at times, one is also kept entertained by the cab drivers with their respective life stories. I had the privilege of being driven around by one such cab driver last October, when I was heading to a friend’s place for our customary weekend party. But for a change, the topic of discussion with the cab driver veered more to the state of Bombay, its lack of infrastructure and the apathy of the ruling class. “How can they be so indifferent to the problems of the city?” the cab driver asked. “Something drastic needs to happen to them, to shake them out of their corrupted, lethargic minds.” With that thought he left me at my destination, only for me to dismiss it completely in an alcohol-induced haze.
The night when the city was awake
A little more than a month later, on 26th November, something happened in Bombay that made me remember the cab driver’s words. Much has been written about the events of that night, and of the next few days so I will not dwell on that here. Suffice to say that after a quick round of phone calls to ensure that everyone in the immediate friends circle was safe, I settled down at home, hoping that my stock of cigarettes would last the vigil. I doubt if most of Mumbai slept that night. Like me, most of them were watching the coverage of the attacks on the television, with ‘expert’ comments coming in frequently, both on television and on the internet. And I thought to myself, maybe this was the drastic action that was really needed. To remind us what we held close. To remind us what can be taken away by a few men with guns. Also to remind us of what we have lost over the years. And to remind us that a constant demand for our rights means nothing without exercising responsibility. The desire to sleep was too overpowering and by 4 am, I switched off the television hoping that the situation would be resolved by the time I woke up.
A world apart
It wasn’t. And it would not be for another couple of days. But this is Bombay and business must continue. Except for the offices in South Bombay, in the areas close to where the NSG operations were still ongoing, it was business as usual. Restaurants were open, cigarette ‘tapri’s’ were open and people were going about their usual, daily life. A friend of mine, Shiv who lives nearby called me out for lunch. He was at a loose end, his office having asked all the employees to skip work for the day due to security considerations. We met at ‘Bagel Shop’, an eatery in Bandra, a place that usually caters to the young urban crowd. Once inside the place, it seemed like a normal Saturday. The conversation too, seemed to be a world apart. Cricket, work, relationships with only a smattering of the events of yesterday. It was almost easy to forget that a pitched gun battle was still happening only 10 km away. It was almost as if by collective will that the events still unfolding were not to be discussed. Or maybe the full extent of the attacks had not yet sunk in to people’s consciousness. This seemed the case for another friend of mine who works in South Bombay. Despite the NSG operation in full flow, he still went to work in the morning, expecting the police to create a safety corridor for office goers. And his office is the building behind the Oberoi Hotel. He returned home, blaming the police for not getting their act together in time.
Candlelight vigils
However, the reactions of the public did not show indifference. Support groups were formed within days, some within hours. All with varying messages. ‘End the corruption.’ ‘Get rid of politicians.’ ‘Mumbai is my city.’ Etc. But these were ordinary, law abiding citizens, not given to venting their anger and frustration through violent means. Blogs, online petitions and candle light vigils were the only possible ways to protest. And people did definitely flock to these forms of protests. Toto’s, a friendly pub in Bandra was one such place where people would discuss such next steps. I went there to drink beer. And ideally, the twain should ne’er meet. An outraged man at our table was exhorting us to join him in a candlelight vigil tomorrow. A girl sitting next to him agreed. As did the rest of the table. Apparently I was the only dissenting voice. Instead, I asked them a few questions. Foremost being – Why? Pat came the reply – To stand up for our rights. I asked them if they considered voting in the upcoming elections. Or if they were registered voters at least. Not a single person was. Without exception. ‘Why was that the case?’ was my follow up question. And the reply too came quickly again, but this time probably with the honesty that is associated with drunkenness. ‘It’s too painful and difficult to get registered in Bombay.’ I smiled inwardly, having received confirmation of what I always suspected. It is always easier to stand up for your rights rather than stand with your responsibilities. As a rejoinder and in an attempt to save face, someone else spoke up – ‘But we should still protest. It sends a message that we will not forget this incident. This is not a one-off protest march. We will continue until whenever necessary.’
The aftermath
I was away from the city on personal matters for the most of the next two months. Bombay crept along fine without me as I expected it would. Also, as expected, the citizen protests petered out. Voter registration was not going as well as expected. Politicians have moved on, now promising sops in exchange of votes. The MNS was in full force again, demanding the change in name of a sweet shop, saying the current name was unpatriotic.
26/11 is still remembered by everyone. But unfortunately, merely remembering this incident is not enough. One must act on it, one must learn from it. Or maybe this event wasn’t drastic enough to shake the apathy and lethargy out. From both citizens and politicians alike. And this may be a bigger tragedy.
Filed under: Genral Rants | 1 Comment »